The open enrollment mistakes California employers make every fall rarely show up right away. They show up three months later, when payroll runs a deduction that’s wrong, an employee calls HR confused about a plan they never understood, or a compliance notice quietly missed its deadline. ServicePro Insurance Solutions is a group health and employee benefits brokerage based in San Diego and Carlsbad, working with employers across California and nationwide, and we watch the same handful of errors repeat every renewal season. None of them are hard to avoid. Most just need someone with the bandwidth to catch them in time.

Mistake #1: Waiting Until the Last Minute to Shop the Market

The most expensive mistake is also the simplest: letting a plan auto-renew because nobody had time to shop it. Carriers count on this. A renewal notice arrives 30 to 45 days before the effective date, HR is stretched thin, and the path of least resistance is to accept whatever number shows up. That number is rarely the carrier’s best offer, it’s the number they can get away with when nobody’s comparing it.

Shopping the market takes real lead time: pulling claims data, requesting competing quotes, and modeling plan design changes before a decision is due. Our 2026 open enrollment checklist for California employers lays out the full 90-day timeline. The short version: if shopping starts the same month enrollment opens, it’s already too late to do it properly.

Mistake #2: Failing to Communicate Plan Changes, and Skipping Employee Education

A plan can be genuinely better than last year’s and still generate complaints if nobody explains what changed. Employees don’t read benefits guides for fun. Someone needs to walk them through what changed in plain language, not just email a PDF and call it done.

This is where employee benefits communication open enrollment efforts fall apart. According to SHRM, most employers now say year-round consultation and personalized enrollment support matter more than a single open enrollment push, yet the biggest gaps brokers and carriers report are exactly what employees need most: clear cost-estimating tools, personalized materials, and enrollment technology that doesn’t require a manual. Skipping employee education sessions doesn’t save time. It just moves the confusion, and the phone calls, to January.

Mistake #3: Missing ACA and California Compliance Notice Deadlines

Open enrollment carries paperwork most HR teams touch once a year, which makes it easy to get wrong. Federal law requires employers to give new hires a Marketplace coverage notice within 14 days of their start date, using the Department of Labor’s current model notice. California adds its own layer on top of that.

Applicable employers must file Forms 1094-C and 1095-C with the California Franchise Tax Board by March 31, with an automatic extension to May 31. The FTB can assess a $50 penalty per individual left off the filing after that. Notices employers routinely forget:

  • An updated Summary of Benefits and Coverage for each plan option offered
  • The annual CHIP notice, where applicable
  • A current Summary Plan Description or Summary of Material Modifications reflecting plan changes

None of these are difficult on their own. They’re just easy to miss when open enrollment is one of a dozen things on an HR manager’s plate that month.

Mistake #4: Not Offering Enough Plan Tiers or Choice

A single medical plan option is simpler to administer, but it forces every employee, from a 24-year-old with no dependents to a 52-year-old supporting a family, into the same deductible and network. That mismatch shows up as low enrollment satisfaction even on a reasonably priced plan.

Offering an HMO and a PPO, or a high-deductible plan with an HSA alongside a richer buy-up option, gives employees a real choice instead of a rubber stamp. The same logic applies to dental and vision and voluntary benefits, a single flat offering rarely fits a workforce spanning multiple life stages. Our post on why disability insurance gets overlooked during open enrollment covers one ancillary line that often gets left off the menu. Reviewing medical plan options across more carriers usually surfaces the tiers worth adding.

Mistake #5: Forgetting to Update Payroll Deductions

This one is entirely avoidable and still happens constantly: enrollment closes, elections get finalized, and payroll keeps running the old deduction amounts because nobody updated the system. Employees notice fast when a paycheck doesn’t match what they signed up for, and unwinding a wrong deduction later is more work than getting it right the first time.

The fix is usually a technology gap, not a people gap. Enrollment platforms that don’t talk to payroll create a manual handoff that’s easy to drop. ServicePro Insurance Solutions’ automated technology solutions connect enrollment elections directly to payroll, so a change made during open enrollment shows up correctly in the next pay run instead of three cycles later.

How a Broker Relationship Fixes Most of These Mistakes

Every mistake above has the same root cause: an HR team, often one or two people, running a specialized annual project on top of their regular job. That’s not a criticism, it’s math. Open enrollment best practices small business owners rely on require dedicated time most HR departments don’t have.

A broker who manages the process end to end changes that math. ServicePro Insurance Solutions handles the market comparison, drafts the compliance notices, runs employee education sessions, and coordinates with payroll, across group health and benefits plans from 50+ carriers, at no cost to the employer. Our process is built around exactly the mistakes covered here. Our piece on why your business needs a group benefits broker goes deeper into that relationship.

Book a Free Consult and we’ll walk through your current plan, your renewal date, and where the gaps are before your next open enrollment window opens.

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the most common open enrollment mistake California employers make?

Letting the plan auto-renew without shopping the market. Carriers rarely lead with their best offer, and employers who don’t compare options against a few competing carriers usually pay more than they need to.

What compliance notices do employers need to send during open enrollment?

At minimum: a Marketplace coverage notice for new hires, an updated Summary of Benefits and Coverage for each plan, and, for applicable California employers, Forms 1094-C and 1095-C filed with the Franchise Tax Board by the March 31 deadline.

How many medical plan options should a small business offer employees?

Most employers land on two or three, commonly an HMO, a PPO, and a high-deductible option, enough to fit different budgets and family situations without adding real administrative weight.

How do I get ServicePro Insurance Solutions involved before my next open enrollment?

Contact us for a review of your current plan and renewal timeline. We’ll flag which mistakes apply to your account and build a shopping and communication plan around your actual renewal date.

Ready to Get Started?

The open enrollment mistakes California employers make are avoidable with the right support in place before the window opens.

Book a Free Consult or call us at (760) 965-7675.

Sources